http://allstargame.elite9hockey.com/pages/results/2025-all-star-game-mvp
| Age Group | Player Name | Program |
| 2012 | Logan Siedlecki | Assabet Patriots |
| 2013 | Max Labrie | Boston Advantage |
| 2014 | Reid Keating | VT. Jr Catamounts |
| 2015 | Ryan O'Neil | Assabet Patriots |
| 2016 | Caleb Malcuit | Boston Advantage |
| 2017 | Matty Walsh | Boston Advantage |
| 2018 | Collin Marcelus | Middlesex Icmen |
| U10 Girls | Annie Labrie | Boston Advantage |
| U12 Girls | Riley Marshall | Boston Americans |
| U14 Girls | Rose Brown | NA Jr. Hawks |